| Year | Name | Team | Position |
| 2016 | Tyler Erwin | Baltimore Orioles | LHP |
| 2015 | Chris Plitt | Pittsburgh Pirates | RHP |
| 2013 | Chris Freudenberg | Chicago White Sox | LHP |
| Scot Hoffman | New York Yankees | RHP | |
| 2012 | Preston Jamison | Detroit Tigers | LHP |
| Taylor Kaczmarek | Los Angeles Dodgers | RHP | |
| 2011 | Trey Ford | Philadelphia Phillies | SS |
| Taylor Wallace | Colorado Rockies | RHP | |
| Jake Williams | Arizona Diamondbacks | 1B | |
| 2010 | Ryan Christenson | Los Angeles Dodgers | LHP |
| Daniel Coulombe | Los Angeles Dodgers | LHP | |
| Trey Ford | Arizona Diamondbacks | SS | |
| Kyle Ottoson | Philadelphia Phillies | LHP | |
| Kenneth Sigman | Arizona Diamondbacks | RHP | |
| 2009 | Dean Espy | Colorado Rockies | 3B |
| Josh Garcia | Arizona Diamondbacks | 1B | |
| Randy Henry | Baltimore Orioloes | RHP/SS | |
| Chase Johnson | Philadelphia Phillies | RHP | |
| Nico Rosthenhausler | Detroit Tigers | OF | |
| 2008 | Adam Bailey | New York Yankees | OF |
| Shane Dyer | Tampa Bay Rays | RHP | |
| Kyle Hurst | Los Angeles Angels | RHP | |
| Adam Prange | St. Louis Cardinals | RHP | |
| Josh Rodriguez | Seattle Mariners | C | |
| Jordan Whatcott | Los Angeles Angels | RHP | |
| 2007 | Cameron Bayne | Cincinnati Reds | P/OF |
| Jayson Brugman | Wash Nationals | INF | |
| Andrew Conklin | Baltimore Orioles | RHP | |
| Jarrett Jackson | Cleveland Indians | 3B/OF | |
| 2006 | Tyson Corley | Chicago White Sox | RHP |
| Alec Shepherd | Detroit Tigers | P/OF | |
| Lucas Miranda | Philadelphia Phillies | P/3B | |
| 2005 | Juan Buck | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| Rene Garcia | Colorado Rockies | RHP | |
| Scott Mueller | Baltimore Orioles | RHP | |
| Kala Kaaihue | Boston Red Sox | C | |
| Kevin McAtee | Detroit Tigers | 1B/3B/OF | |
| Luis Nieblas | Independent | C | |
| CJ Retherford | Chicago White Sox | 3B | |
| 2004 | Luis Cota | Kansas City Royals | RHP |
| Gabe Suarez | Montreal Expos | SS | |
| Joshua Tarnow | Detroit Tigers | C | |
| Max Leon | Detroit | 2B | |
| 2002 | Chris Honsa | Philadelphia Phillies | RHP |
| Anthony Moreno | San Francisco Giants | RHP | |
| David Nowak | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B | |
| Joey Newby | Oakland Athletics | RHP | |
| 2001 | Beau Vaughan | Boston Red Sox | RHP |
| Eddie Menchaca | Seattle Mariners | SS | |
| Chris Collins | Seattle Mariners | C | |
| Joshua Perrault | Arizona Diamondbacks | RHP | |
| Joey Reiman | Toronto Blue Jays | 1B | |
| Mike Guerrero | Arizona Diamondbacks | 1B | |
| 2000 | Jon Schaeffer | New York Yankees | OF |
| Chris Duffy | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF | |
| Drew Hassler | Baltimore Orioles | RHP | |
| Doug White | Independent | RHP | |
| 1999 | Paul Rottman | Arizona Diamondbacks | 1B |
| Troy Ransom | San Francisco Giants | RHP | |
| Derek Forbes | Arizona Diamondbacks | RHP | |
| Kelly Martin | Cincinnati Reds | RHP | |
| Jason Tibesar | Arizona Diamondbacks | OF | |
| Dallas Haught | Tampa Bay Devil Rays | OF | |
| 1998 | D Cowan | Independent | 3B |
| Justin Cowan | Kansas City Royals | C | |
| Sammy Cooper | San Diego Padres | SS | |
| 1995 | Greg Smith | Independent | LHP |
| Cody Ransom* | San Francisco Giants | SS | |
| Robert Hewes | Texas Rangers | 2B | |
| 1994 | Todd Eastin | San Francisco Giants | C |
| 1989 | Scott Lydy* | Oakland Athletics | OF |
| 1984 | Miguel Echavaria | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1983 | Richard Caldwell | Baltimore Orioles | RHP |
*Played in MLB